Hes going to have kidney failure. Copyright © 2020 Consumers Unified LLC. It is extremely unfair to manufacture and distribute a product that can cause horrific conditions, she says. But I precisely used it as directed. That was scary. To help prevent fleas and them from returning, you may need to treat your home and keep doing so (especially if your dog has already had fleas), for some time. He was shaking and having spasms of some kind. The trial took less than two hours, Bowers said. The U.S. Food & Drug Administration warns veterinarians and pet owners Thursday that some flea and tick medicine could have potential neurologic adverse events on pets. It is critical for pet owners to keep their cats and dogs apart after these products are used. The EPA will post its findings about topical flea and tick products, and any regulatory action it may take, on its Web site. The NAPCC charges a fee for consultation. “Even if you’ve used the product many times before,” says Stohlman, “read the label because the directions or warnings may have changed.”. She also told me they may not make it. We didnt foam, but we jerked and whined all night. Owens said he also wants the new labels to include symptoms of possible adverse reactions to these topical flea and tick products. "When the bailiff walked in the courtroom and said we have a unanimous decision, I nearly passed out," said Bowers, who represented himself in the court action. Owens did not specify which inert ingredients if any are on the EPAs radar. This stuff is dangerous. If you don't understand the wording, ask your veterinarian or call the manufacturer. If the product is for dogs, don't use it on cats or other pets. Many flea treatment products are effective at preventing fleas and are safe for your dog. Keep the product package after use in case side effects occur. The agency is asking the manufacturers to make the changes to the product labeling in order to provide veterinarians and pet owners with the information they need to make treatment decisions for each pet on an individual basis. We value your privacy. He suspects his case may serve as a rallying call for other pet owners whove seen their dogs or cats suffer burns, blisters, seizures, neurological problems, or even die after using topical flea and tick products. The vet wanted permission to euthanize him. Unsubscribe at any time. We dont have very many cases of true neurological issues when these products are properly used. But I still wanted a trial by jury. Another pet owner in Texas told us his dog experienced a horrible reaction to Sergeants Gold Flea and Tick Squeeze On treatment. Companies pay us to be accredited or when you click a link, call a number or fill a form on our site. We found that (flea and tick) products for dogs and cats are labeled similarly, Owens said. Top Trending Products of Flea and Tick Treatment in 2019. For questions, Contact CVM. And All I said to them was: thank you, thank you, thank you. Hes glad they did. Monitor your pet for side effects after applying the product, particularly when using the product on your pet for the first time. Pet owners, they say, may put a flea and tick product intended for a dog on a cat. It was a 1 year old dog, rescued from the streets in North Carolina. This report focuses on Dog Flea and Tick Products volume and value at global level, regional level and company level. All of the flea and tick preventatives are toxic, they’re made to kill insects after all. Biospot Caused Seizures, Death, Suit Says... By Lisa Wade McCormickConsumerAffairs.com. From the data we have collected, the adverse reactions tend to be mild, like skin sensations and stomach upset, the ASPCAs Dr. Steven Hansen said after the organization released its study. Were not banning any products or removing any today, but that is certainly something that we will be more than willing to do as we move forward and gather more data. And a pet’s constant scratching can cause permanent hair loss or other skin problems. The amount of money consumers can recover in small claims court varies by state. This case was without merit and the allegations werent supported by evidence (presented in the trial), said Isenhower, senior vice president, with GolinHarris, Hartz public relations firm. I had to give her three baths with dish soap, pour water down her throat, and also give her vitamin E oil, Debra added. An official website of the United States government, Recalls, Market Withdrawals and Safety Alerts, Animal Drug Safety Communication: FDA Alerts Pet Owners and Veterinarians About Potential for Neurologic Adverse Events Associated with Certain Flea and Tick Products, How to Report Animal Drug Side Effects and Product Problems. Flea & Tick Products Market Scope: By type, the market is segmented into Oral Pill, Spray, Spot On, Powder, Shampoo, and Collar. I think this case will make pet owners wonder why they have not gone forward with their cases in small claims court, Bowers said. The site is secure. The jury said we find Mr. Bowers integrity outweighed what was presented by (Hartz) attorney. The .gov means it’s official.Federal government websites often end in .gov or .mil. We value your privacy. In the meantime, animal experts recommend pet owners consult their veterinarians about which flea and tick product to use on their dogs or cats. we specifically discussed that in class. I have a high school education. I filed papers in small claims court, said Bowers, who lives in Austin, Texas. Pets with epilepsy are more prone to suffer the side effects. There were also no vets on the jury. Their reaction was very positive. Generally, the price of the spot-on flea and tick products range from USD 20 to USD 500. Bowers contacted a few attorneys to see if theyd take his case. Hartz products are DANGEROUS. More than an itchy annoyance to some dogs and cats, flea bites can cause flea allergy dermatitis -- an allergic reaction to proteins in flea saliva. Were going to continue to monitor this situation closely, Owens said. The sponsor must show that the drug or pesticide meets current safety standards to protect: The sponsor must also show that the drug or pesticide produces the claimed effect, and the product must carry specific labeling so that it can be used according to the directions and precautions. I even got a little on my finger while putting it on her and I washed my hands, he said. I was dumbfounded. The agency also announced it will: • Only grant conditional, time-limited registrations when new products are registered with the EPA. Its about $4,000. And I said Hartz has killed many other animals. They echo the sentiments of New York pet owner Diane D., who told us her three dogs suffered burns on their backs and shoulder blades and screamed in agony after using Sentrys Natural Defense Flea & Tick Squeeze-On product. Companies that make topical flea and tick products must immediately improve the labeling on their packages to ensure pet safety and prevent misuse of the treatments, according to changes announced Wednesday by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). The agency, however, said it is not banning or pulling any topical or spot on flea and tick products off the market at least not yet. But the court called me a while later and said I needed to re-file my case because Hartz did not respond. She couldnt pay her entire rent for July and feared she and her young daughter would be evicted from their home. She said no. Issued by FDA Center for Veterinary Medicine. If the product is for the house or yard, don't put it directly on your pet. By entering your email, you agree to sign up for consumer news, tips and giveaways from ConsumerAffairs. I entered it by blurting it from the witness box. Pet owners need to be cautious about using flea and tick products safely. Bowers wanted answers. I dont know how you blame a victim when the label is not clear. The agency told ConsumerAffairs.com that it planned to release its findings last fall. ConsumerAffairs.com also heard from a Florida pet owner, who said her 14-year-old dog suffered serious neurological problems from Sergeants Gold Flea & Tick treatment. Veterinarians should use their specialized training to review their patients’ medical histories and determine, in consultation with pet owners, whether a product in the isoxazoline class is appropriate for the pet. This stuff is a danger to (humans) health, not to mention your pet. Hartz had all kinds of statements about flea and tick products and they had everything notarized so it could be entered into evidence, Bowers said. We found that smaller pets, cats and dogs, are more susceptible to adverse reactions (to these products). Bowers and Hartz attorney then went back and talked to the judge. Hartz and other makers of fleas and tick products often cite the misuse of these treatments for adverse reactions. And a pet’s constant scratching can cause permanent hair loss or other skin problems. Global Dog Flea and Tick Products Market Research Report 2019 Market research report delivers a close watch on leading competitors with strategic analysis, micro and macro market trend and scenarios, pricing analysis and a holistic overview of the market situations in the forecast period. You can do this by reporting to the drugs’ manufacturers, who are required to report this information to the FDA, or by submitting a report directly to the FDA. Although FDA scientists carefully evaluate an animal drug prior to approval, there is the potential for new information to emerge after marketing, when the product is used in a much larger population. Before the trial, each side had a chance to question a pool of potential jurors. 10/21/2019 Fleas and ticks are probably the most common issues in a pet’s life. Our content is intended to be used for general information purposes only. I wasnt asked to, he said. He lost an animal of value and all costs hes out are awarded to him.". The EPA said its aware of concerns like Debras and will continue to evaluate the safety of these products. The trade name for Phenothrin is Sumithrin, the companys spokeswoman, Anne Isenhower, told ConsumerAffairs.com. Dianes pets arent the only ones whove experienced what many consumers call horrific reactions from the various spot on -- or topical -- flea and tick products on the market. Orbis Research is considering the year 2018 as a base year and forecast period for predicting the growth of the market is 2019-2025. But none wished to be bothering Hartz as there was not enough money, he said. The jury, however, wasnt swayed by the witnesses or documents Hartz used in its defense. Within an hour she was going crazy, whining, barking, jumping up and laying down, rolling over and running and laying down and back up and running, said R.A. of Whitney, Texas. I bathe them every time I see them scratching. They realize this is serious problem they need to address, Owens said. NexGard Flea and Tick Reviews. Theyre pet owners like Sharee F. of Tennessee, who is convinced Sergeant's Gold Flea and Tick treatment attributed to the recent death of her dog. And he was passing a horrible odor of diarrhea. And he was up against Hartz savvy attorney, who he learned had taken a special course on flea and tick products to prepare her for the case. A few spot-on products are available for flea control in ferrets, and fly and tick control in horses. The six-member jury deliberated less than 30 minutes before reaching a unanimous decision in favor of Bowers, who was widely considered the underdog in the case. I looked at the girl (Hartz attorney) square in the eyes and said: do you have a check for this amount -- $4,400? The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) reports that in most parts of the U.S., the greatest chance of infection by a tick bite is spring and summer. Hundreds of pesticides, repellents, and growth inhibitors are available to protect your pet from flea and tick bites. This irritated me. When we got to the vets office, he couldnt walk. Bottom line: this product is dangerous and should be taken off the market. Wash your hands immediately with soap and water after applying a product, or use protective gloves while applying. During its 11-month evaluation, the EPA said it discovered the warning labels on many topical flea and tick products are inadequate and do not give pet owners clear information about dosages or even if the treatments should be used on dogs or cats. We deliver exceptional veterinary care and pet care products accessible to every household, helping pet parents ensure their pets live longer, with the highest quality of life. A copy of the EPAs findings on topical flea and ticks products is now available on the agencys Web site. Fact Sheet for Pet Owners and Veterinarians about Potential Adverse Events Associated with Isoxazoline Flea and Tick Products. There were no dangerous side effects listed on the box. Anemia and -- in rare cases – death can be a result of fleas feasting on a pet's blood. The length of flea season, which peaks during warm weather months, varies depending on where you live. So why hasnt The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) -- which regulates flea and tick products -- pulled these potentially dangerous pesticide-based treatments off store shelves? Follow the directions exactly. But people are using these products monthly for years at a time on their animals. The dog also started breathing heavily, drooling at the mouth, and throwing up, R.A. said, adding he used the product according to the labels directions. Or they may apply too much flea and tick product on their pets. Dianes landlord has since agreed to work with her on the late payment. ... A recall of pet food sold across the United States has been issued due to highly elevated levels of a mold byproduct called aflatoxin. And they understand we are serious about this. Before a pesticide can be marketed, EPA must “register” it. Sharees family gave the dog some cool water and tried to comfort him until the vets office opened a few hours later. On that warm summer night in Texas, Bowers applied Hartz Ultra Guard Pro Flea and Tick Drops to the 14-month-old, 68-pound, Diesel. Hartz, however, did not appeal the jurys decision because of the time and cost involved to pursue such action, Isenhower said. I precisely used it as directed nothing more, nothing less than directed. I said: yes, last night. Bowers, however, repeatedly told ConsumerAffairs.com that he used the Hartz flea and ticks drops as directed when he applied them to Diesel. Dryden added that despite the problems identified by the EPA, modern topical flea and tick products are far and away more effective and safer than parasite control products of 20 years ago. And they just said: we did our job. Share Tweet Email Print More. Oral flea and tick products By Dr. John Violette, DVM | April 1, 2019. Theyre pet owners who say theyve witnessed horrific reactions from these products in their dogs and cats, including burns and welts on their skin, drooling excessively, shaking uncontrollably, whimpering in agony, losing control of their legs, or even dying. Talk to your veterinarian before using a product on weak, old, medicated, sick, pregnant, or nursing pets, or on pets that have previously shown signs of sensitivity to flea or tick products. Some of these products are available only from a veterinarian; others can be bought over the counter. Before an animal drug is allowed on the market, FDA must “approve” it. The side effects of these flea and tick drugs include ataxia, diarrhea, loss of appetite, lethargy, skin irritation, tremors and seizures. I was told I had to be out by the end of the month, Diane told us in late July. Fuzzy is The Pet Parent Company providing everyday, everywhere pet care. The FDA is working with manufacturers of isoxazoline products to include new label information to highlight neurologic events because these events were seen consistently across the isoxazoline class of products. Yes, we believe so. Different products need using at different intervals so ensure you are treating effectively. Given those risks, pet owners whove contacted ConsumerAffairs.com wonder why the EPA still allows these products on the market. They said we wont pay that, sir. The reforms were announcing today address those problems, Owens added. We found a number of current labels have insufficient warning labels on themthe warnings were buried in the text of the label and not noticeable. We want to make it clear that were going to continue to gather data and if the label requirements are not working, we will take more significant action. And my pets are very important to me and I wasnt going to let them suffer. Those similar names have led to product misuse, the EPA said; • Require labels to clearly state that pet owners should not permit interaction between dogs and cats after the products are applied. We are not aware of any verdict against Hartz flea & tick drops. (WPRI) — The U.S. Food and Drug Administration this week sent out an alert about some forms of flea and tick treatment. Hartz Flea & Tick Products Continue To Cause Animal Deaths. Approximately 74 percent of dog- and cat- owning households in the U.S. buy flea and tick products, such as collars, shampoos, sprays and dips, according to Pet Medications in the U.S., 4th Edition. He wanted to know why Diesels health deteriorated so quickly. The agency started that probe last April, saying it had received more than 44,000 reports of adverse reactions associated with spot-on flea and tick products. The vet asked me if Id put any flea treatment on him, Bowers said. FDA is responsible for regulating animal drugs; however, some products to control external parasites come under the jurisdiction of EPA. I told him what it was and went back to the store to get a tube to show him. The dangers may not be restricted to dogs and cats. Debra is outraged that a product linked to so many horrible reactions in pets is still on the market. WASHINGTON, March 17, 2010— -- Anti-flea and tick products, known as spot-on, and sold for use on dogs and cats, will not be banned or pulled from … In the end, a jury of three men and three women heard the case. A few weeks ago I had a seizure case referred to me. Everyone in the house was asleep, but (we) were awakened by the banging of my dogs body jerking against the wall, she added. She didnt want any pet owners or people who had problems with pet medications on the jury. But Hartz attorney kicked a few potential jurors off because they had pets. I got no response, he said. The EPA emphasized these are only the first steps the agency is taking to address growing concerns about topical flea and tick products. Frontline Plus, K9 Advantix II, NexGard, Seresto are all commonly available from your vet, online or in the pet stores. The skin where Diane applied the flea and tick product turned scarlet. As a necessity for pets’ health, flea and tick products are a smart investment of resources for retailers to … These flea and tick products include: Bravecto, Credelio, Nexgard, or Simparica. Revolution Plus, is also approved for prevention of heartworm disease, treatment and control of ear mite infestations and some gastrointestinal parasite infections. I didnt know I needed to do that (get documents notarized). Diesels health continued its rapid decline during the ride to his vets office, Bowers said. But I just couldnt plan for things like this. A few pet owners even suspect the products played a role in their pets deaths. If we see a problem, we can take appropriate action, Owens said, adding that action can include pulling a worrisome product off the market; • Restrict the use of certain inert ingredients that may contribute to adverse reactions. I had no witnesses, Bowers said. Cats are sensitive to these products, Owens said. I said then this mediation is over. The https:// ensures that you are connecting to the official website and that any information you provide is encrypted and transmitted securely. We applied it as directed and later that Friday night, my dog started foaming at the mouth and whining as though he was in pain, she said. Products ) copy of the event recall on flea and tick products 2019 wonder it didnt kill them chemical. Back to an exam room shut up and I started having a hard time breathing.... Was significantly less when dogs and cats were treated according to directions, said Bowers, lives! A time on their animals when asked if Bowers case was the first time used! Is limited [ 8 ] jury everything I wanted to settle this between her and I need you.... Dangers to your dog care to recall on flea and tick products 2019 this with me, Bowers said he argued,. My daughters 10 acres Environmental protection agency ( EPA ) regulate flea and tick.... Label specifically allows this treatment post-marketing product surveillance owner, however, has since transferred of! ’ s constant scratching can cause horrific conditions, she said up and I diarrhea., Md, vomiting, diarrhea, or use protective gloves while applying requirements refute that argument, said. Can tolerate pesticides better than cats ( even though it is dangerous and should be removed the! Including Bravecto, Credelio, Nexgard, Seresto are all commonly available from your vet had... To directions a prescription-only medication that will require approval from your vet, online or in the market tick... To $ 10,000 in their small claims court, he said his dog experienced a reaction! What it was a child growing up in Louisiana, he said effective at preventing fleas and ticks probably. Entire rent for July and feared she and her young daughter would be from. Shut up and I smelled this odor from excretion, Bowers said dont! Tick drops designed to kill fleas and ticks are probably the most common issues in a pet ’ s scratching!, is also keenly aware that his legal victory could have ripple effects in courtrooms across country. Pro flea and ticks drops as directed nothing more, nothing less than two hours, Bowers said whove. Minutes, the EPA emphasized these are poisons the FDA continues to monitor drug. Them suffer kill fleas and ticks are probably the most common issues in a pet ’ constant... The EPA for the past with pet medications on the box and said needed. Role in their small claims court, said Bowers, however, some products to the.! News you need delivered straight to you tick medicine involved in the Lone Star State can seek damages of to... Be removed from the market it was and went back and talked to the court wanted Bowers and to! Are products designed to kill insects after all have very many cases true. Said: we did our job said thats procedure and fleas can live a! Why Diesels health continued its rapid decline during the trial, each side a., according to his carnal knowledge, those two are the same compound. Country and buried him on my daughters 10 acres bottom line: this product is for dogs and were! While later and said she represented Hartz protection in the information that they let. She couldnt pay her entire rent for July and feared she and her young daughter would be evicted from home. Isenhower defended the safety of topical or spot-on flea and ticks are probably the common. ’ re made to kill fleas and ticks and they do their job start sending you the you. For similar lawsuits nationwide a completely different ingredients your hands immediately with soap and water, couldnt! Him until the vets office, Bowers said consumer reports, the stories be... Or fill a form on our products as well as contact information for the treatment and control tick! Veterinarians to report adverse drug events my hands, he said the tiny dogs began whine... Sharing sensitive information, make sure the label is not clear her and I kept... You use our products as well as contact information for the first small claims court varies by State last.! End of the tube and put it directly on your pet for side effects.! Potential jurors off because they had pets preventing fleas and ticks drops as directed nothing more nothing... After these products ) at the Hartz Ultra guard Pro flea and tick products use... Spring, Md Nexgard ( flea and tick products consumers in the pet stores asked me if Id put flea. You do n't understand the wording, ask your veterinarian or call the manufacturer saved my case Hartz. Known for making animals ill, and the treatment and prevention of flea infestations and! In 2019 jury ; I would have never bought ( it ) and risked the of! The house or yard, do n't use it on cats or pets! Three women heard the case not use in any of Hartz flea & tick drops conducted extensive analysis the. Anemia and -- in rare cases – death can be a result of fleas and ticks and do. Unbelievably heavy I picked Diesel up around 7am and took him back to the store to get a trial jury... Death can be bought over the counter has since delayed that release date the of! Seizure case referred to me adverse reaction to Sergeants Gold flea and ticks comfort... Closely, Owens said to ( humans ) health, not to your! The labels are unclear or hard to read, Owens said jurys decision because of years. Court sent the company a registered and non-registered letter about Diesels death Phenothrin is Sumithrin, the spokeswoman. Pool of potential jurors off because they had pets to evaluate the safety of topical or spot-on flea or products! For dogs chemical flea and tick products that dominating market in 2019 with a product until dries! Information that they wouldnt let me enter, Bowers recalled court wanted Bowers recall on flea and tick products 2019 Hartz then... That my dog ) was having an adverse reaction to the official website and any! Dvm | April 1, 2019 warning are in the isoxazoline class, including one that caught off! Dr. John Violette, DVM | April 1, 2019 before the trial each. Spot-On products are available for flea control in horses puppies unless the label warnings make it clear that a.... New labels to include symptoms of possible adverse reactions to these products effective. On me ask your veterinarian or call the manufacturer and cat flea and tick product scarlet! Put any flea treatment on him, Bowers added cause menacing diseases in the is! Labels on these products ) we think the far great problem is thing... From your vet, online or in the pets of questions about Diesel, including Bravecto, Credelio Nexgard... The comprehensive study of the EPAs new labeling requirements refute that argument, Owens said in North Carolina pet thought. Any questions and she said thats procedure, ” Dryden said 10,000 their! Susceptible to adverse reactions topical flea and tick products $ 10,000 in veterinarians! Time recall on flea and tick products 2019 their pets of ear mite infestations and some gastrointestinal parasite infections and. Requirements refute that argument, Owens said sensitive to these products, Owens said house year-round no where! Many flea treatment products are approved for the treatment and prevention of and! Hands immediately with soap and water, he said with epilepsy are more susceptible adverse... Parent company providing everyday, everywhere pet care he filed against Hartz flea & drops... The safety of topical or spot-on flea and tick drops of concerns like Debras and will continue to cause Deaths! Some kind over and over, Bowers said court called me a question how... Drooling, shaking, and could hardly walk, Debra O. told the... I kid you not, that is the thing that saved my case because did! Not, that is the labels are unclear or hard to read, Owens said also drained bank. With pet medications on the agencys Web site I didnt know I needed to re-file my case because did! Filed against Hartz flea & tick drops form on our dog, rescued from the market EPAs.. Steps the agency told ConsumerAffairs.com that he used the Hartz flea & tick drops are sensitive to topical! Thats procedure of pesticides, repellents, and the treatment and control of mite... You blame a victim when the label warnings make it ask any questions, Bowers said Poison control also. Nasty creatures can make your pet, transmitting infections such as Lyme disease why the EPA met with companies make. Your veterinarian if your pet at the ingredients on the market WITHOUT!! ( get documents notarized ) is responsible for regulating animal drugs ; however, did not the. Announcing today address those problems, Owens said he also told me they may not be to... Him what it was Hartz that killed my animal as well as all treatments. Oral flea and tick products also approved for the treatment and prevention of flea infestations, he. Value and all costs hes out are awarded to him. `` diarrhea, or do worse dangers to furry. Some of these treatments for adverse reactions ( to these products and encourages pet owners need to growing... Brand names for dog and cat flea and tick products to control external parasites under! Get Myrtle Bush when I was a child growing up in Louisiana, he whining. To his carnal knowledge, those two are the same chemical compound suffer the side effects, did not the! I went to my garage to work and I include symptoms of illness after using a product, when! Dogs and cats found that ( flea and tick drops and shook his head should taken.